Skip to main content
How to Choose and Set Up Your First CRM
Guide Beginner | | 15 min read

How to Choose and Set Up Your First CRM

Every small business eventually hits the same wall. You are managing customers across sticky notes, spreadsheets, email threads, and your own memory. A lead comes in and you forget to follow up. A repeat customer calls and you cannot remember what you discussed last time. You have no idea which of your marketing efforts are actually generating revenue because nothing is connected to anything.

A CRM — Customer Relationship Management software — solves all of this. It is a single system that stores every customer interaction, tracks every deal in progress, and gives you visibility into your sales pipeline so nothing slips through the cracks. For businesses that depend on relationships and repeat customers (which is most small businesses), a CRM is not a luxury. It is infrastructure.

But choosing the wrong CRM, or setting up the right one poorly, creates more problems than it solves. This guide walks you through evaluating your needs, choosing the right tool, setting it up properly, and actually getting your team to use it.

What a CRM Actually Does (and Does Not Do)

Before evaluating tools, you need to understand what you are buying.

What a CRM Does

Contact management: A single database of every person and company your business interacts with. Every phone call, email, meeting, purchase, and support request is logged in one place. When a customer calls, you can see their complete history in seconds.

Sales pipeline tracking: A visual representation of every deal in progress, organized by stage (new lead, contacted, proposal sent, negotiation, won, lost). You can see at a glance how much revenue is in your pipeline, where deals are stalling, and what needs attention today.

Task and follow-up management: Automated reminders to follow up with leads, check in with customers, send proposals, and complete tasks. The CRM makes sure nothing falls through the cracks, even when you are busy.

Communication tracking: Logs of every email, call, and text message associated with each contact. You never have to search through your inbox to find that conversation from three months ago.

Reporting: Data on your sales activity, conversion rates, revenue forecasts, and team performance. Instead of guessing how your business is doing, you have actual numbers.

What a CRM Does Not Do

  • It does not replace doing the work. A CRM tracks and organizes your customer relationships. It does not build those relationships for you. You still need to make the calls, send the proposals, and deliver great service.
  • It does not work if nobody uses it. The most expensive CRM in the world is worthless if your team enters data inconsistently or not at all. Adoption is the single biggest challenge and we will address it directly.
  • It is not a marketing platform (usually). Some CRMs include email marketing, social media management, and advertising tools. Most do not. Know what you need and do not pay for features you will never use.

Step 1: Define What You Actually Need

The CRM market is enormous and overwhelming. There are hundreds of options ranging from free to $300+ per user per month. The only way to navigate it is to start with your specific requirements, not with feature comparison charts.

Answer These Questions

How many people will use the CRM? Just you? A sales team of 3? Your whole company of 15? This affects pricing (most CRMs charge per user) and the level of complexity you need.

What is your primary use case?

  • Tracking sales leads and deals through a pipeline
  • Managing ongoing customer relationships and service
  • Organizing contacts and communication history
  • All of the above

What tools do you already use that the CRM needs to connect with?

  • Email provider (Gmail, Outlook, etc.)
  • Calendar
  • Accounting software (QuickBooks, Xero)
  • Phone system
  • Website forms
  • Marketing tools

What is your budget? Be honest about what you can sustain monthly. A CRM is a long-term commitment, and switching CRMs later is painful. It is better to start with something affordable that you will keep than something expensive that you will abandon.

How technical is your team? Some CRMs require significant setup and customization. Others work out of the box. Be realistic about your team’s willingness and ability to learn new software.

Start with pain points, not features. Write down the 3-5 specific problems you need the CRM to solve. "I lose track of follow-ups." "I do not know which leads are hot." "I cannot tell which marketing channels generate actual customers." Evaluate every CRM against these specific problems, not against a generic feature list.

Step 2: Evaluate Your Options

With your requirements defined, here is how to navigate the market without getting lost.

CRM Categories for Small Businesses

Simple and affordable (1-10 users, basic needs): These CRMs focus on contact management, deal tracking, and basic automation. They are easy to set up, have shorter learning curves, and cost $0-$30 per user per month.

Best for: Solo operators, small teams, businesses that need organization more than automation.

Mid-range (5-50 users, growing businesses): These add marketing automation, deeper reporting, more integrations, and customization options. They cost $30-$80 per user per month.

Best for: Businesses with dedicated sales teams, companies doing active outbound sales, businesses with complex sales processes.

Enterprise (50+ users, complex needs): Salesforce, Microsoft Dynamics, and similar platforms. Extremely powerful and extremely complex. They require dedicated administrators, consultants for setup, and months of implementation.

Best for: Not you. Not yet. If you are reading a guide called “How to Choose Your First CRM,” enterprise platforms will overwhelm you and drain your budget.

What to Evaluate

Ease of use: Can you navigate the interface without reading a manual? The best CRM is the one your team will actually use. Request a trial and try to add a contact, create a deal, and log a phone call. If it takes more than 5 minutes to figure out, it is too complex for your needs right now.

Mobile app: If you or your team work in the field, the mobile experience matters as much as the desktop experience. Test the mobile app specifically — many CRMs have mediocre mobile interfaces that make field use frustrating.

Integrations: Does it connect with your email, calendar, and other critical tools? Native integrations (built into the CRM) are more reliable than third-party connectors, but tools like Zapier can fill gaps.

Pricing transparency: Watch for CRMs that advertise a low base price but charge extra for essential features like email integration, phone logging, or reporting. Calculate the actual monthly cost for your team with the features you need.

Data import and export: Can you easily import your existing contacts (from spreadsheets, email, or another CRM)? Can you export your data if you ever decide to switch? If a CRM makes it hard to leave, that should concern you.

Our recommendation for small businesses: SMBcrm was built specifically for small business owners who need pipeline management, contact tracking, and follow-up automation without the complexity and cost of enterprise platforms. It is designed to be set up in an afternoon, not over six months with a consultant. If your team is under 20 people and you need a CRM that works immediately, it is worth a look.

The Trial Period Strategy

Most CRMs offer a 14-30 day free trial. Here is how to use that time effectively:

  1. Day 1-2: Import 20-30 real contacts and create 5-10 real deals in your pipeline. Use real data, not test data — you need to see how the CRM handles your actual workflow.
  2. Day 3-7: Use the CRM as your primary system for managing those contacts and deals. Log every call, email, and meeting. Set follow-up reminders.
  3. Day 8-14: Evaluate honestly. Did you actually open the CRM every day? Was it helpful or did it feel like extra work? Could you find what you needed quickly?

If you are not using the CRM consistently during a free trial — when your motivation is highest — you will not use it after you start paying.

Step 3: Set Up Your CRM the Right Way

More CRMs fail from bad setup than from bad software. A well-configured simple CRM beats a poorly configured powerful one every time.

Import Your Existing Contacts

Start by getting your current contacts into the system:

  1. Consolidate your contact sources. Gather contacts from your email, phone, spreadsheets, business card apps, and any other tools you are currently using.
  2. Clean your data before importing. Remove duplicates, fix obvious errors, and standardize formatting (especially phone numbers and addresses). This is tedious but critical. Garbage in, garbage out.
  3. Map your fields. Match the columns in your spreadsheet to the fields in your CRM. First name, last name, email, phone, company — make sure everything lands in the right place.
  4. Do a test import. Import 10-20 contacts first and verify they look correct before importing everything.

Customize Your Sales Pipeline

Most CRMs come with a default pipeline that looks something like: Lead → Contacted → Qualified → Proposal → Negotiation → Won/Lost. This might work for you, or it might not match your actual sales process at all.

Customize your pipeline stages to reflect how you actually sell:

For a home services company:

Inquiry → Estimate Scheduled → Estimate Sent → Follow-up → Booked → Completed → Review Requested

For a B2B consultant:

Discovery Call → Needs Assessment → Proposal Sent → Under Review → Contract Sent → Won/Lost

For a retail or e-commerce business:

New Lead → Engaged → Quote Requested → Quote Sent → Order Placed → Delivered

Keep it simple. Start with 5-7 stages maximum. You can always add stages later. Too many stages at the start create confusion and make the pipeline hard to read.

Set Up Custom Fields

Every business tracks information that does not fit in standard CRM fields. Add custom fields for the data points that matter to your business:

  • Lead source: Where the contact came from (Google, referral, Facebook, event). This is critical for understanding which marketing channels work.
  • Service type or product interest: What they are looking for.
  • Budget range: If applicable to your sales process.
  • Key dates: Contract renewal dates, project deadlines, birthdays.
  • Notes or preferences: Any information that helps you personalize the relationship.

Do not add 30 custom fields on day one. Start with 3-5 that you will actually fill in for every contact, and add more as your needs become clear.

Configure Automation

Even basic CRMs offer some automation. Set these up early to save time from day one:

  • New lead notification: Get an email or app notification when a new lead enters your pipeline (from a web form, for example).
  • Follow-up reminders: Automatic tasks created when a deal sits in a stage for too long. If a proposal has been “Sent” for 5 days, create a follow-up task.
  • Welcome email: An automatic email when a new contact is added, confirming receipt of their inquiry and setting expectations for next steps.
  • Activity reminders: Daily or weekly digests showing your upcoming tasks, overdue follow-ups, and stale deals.
The two-week rule: If a deal sits in any pipeline stage for more than two weeks without activity, something is wrong. Either the deal is dead (move it to Lost), it needs a follow-up (create a task), or the stage does not reflect reality (update it). Stale pipelines give you a false sense of business health. Set up automation that flags deals with no activity for 14+ days.

Step 4: Build Habits That Stick

The CRM is only as good as the data inside it. And the data is only as good as your team’s discipline in entering it. This is where most CRM implementations fail — not at setup, but at adoption.

The Daily CRM Routine

Establish a non-negotiable daily routine for every CRM user:

Start of day (5 minutes):

  • Open the CRM dashboard
  • Review today’s tasks and follow-ups
  • Check for new leads that came in overnight

Throughout the day (as it happens):

  • Log every customer call and meeting immediately after it happens (not “later” — later never comes)
  • Update deal stages when something changes
  • Add notes after significant conversations

End of day (5 minutes):

  • Review what was accomplished
  • Move any incomplete tasks to tomorrow
  • Make sure all deals reflect their current status

Make It the Path of Least Resistance

People use the tools that are easiest. If entering data in the CRM is harder than writing it on a sticky note, the sticky note wins every time.

  • Set the CRM as your browser’s homepage so it is the first thing you see.
  • Use the mobile app to log calls and notes immediately, before you forget.
  • Connect your email so conversations are logged automatically instead of manually.
  • Use the CRM for meeting prep — before every customer call, pull up their record. This creates a positive feedback loop where the CRM is useful because it has data, and it has data because people use it.

Getting Your Team on Board

If you have employees who need to use the CRM:

  • Explain the “why” before the “how.” “We are implementing a CRM” generates resistance. “We are going to stop losing leads and forgetting follow-ups” generates buy-in.
  • Start with one team or one process. Do not roll out the CRM to everyone for everything on day one. Start with your sales team (or yourself) and the lead-to-customer pipeline. Expand once that is working smoothly.
  • Make it a team norm, not a personal preference. If some people use the CRM and others do not, the data is incomplete and the system breaks down. Everyone participates or it does not work.
  • Remove the old tools. If people can still use the spreadsheet, they will. Once the CRM is set up and working, retire the old systems.

Step 5: Measure What Matters

Once your CRM has 30-60 days of data, you can start extracting insights that actually inform business decisions.

Key Metrics to Track

Pipeline value: The total dollar value of all deals currently in your pipeline. This tells you how much potential revenue is in play.

Conversion rate by stage: What percentage of leads move from one stage to the next? If 100 leads enter your pipeline but only 5 make it to the proposal stage, you have a qualification or engagement problem. If 50 get proposals but only 5 close, you have a pricing or proposal problem.

Average deal cycle time: How long does it take from first contact to closed deal? This helps you forecast revenue and identify bottlenecks. If deals are taking 60 days to close but most of that time is spent waiting for proposals, you know where to focus.

Lead source performance: Which channels produce the most leads? More importantly, which channels produce the most closed deals? You might get 50 leads from Facebook but close only 2, while 10 referral leads close 7. Without a CRM tracking lead source through to close, you would never see this.

Activity metrics: How many calls, emails, and meetings is your team logging? Low activity usually correlates with low results. If a salesperson’s pipeline is empty, the activity metrics usually explain why.

Using CRM Data to Make Decisions

  • Double down on what works. If referral leads close at 5x the rate of social media leads, invest more in your referral program and less in social media advertising.
  • Fix the bottleneck. If deals stall consistently at the same pipeline stage, that stage needs attention. Maybe your proposals take too long to send, or your follow-up cadence is too slow.
  • Forecast revenue. With enough historical data, you can predict how much revenue will close next month based on your current pipeline and conversion rates. This makes budgeting and hiring decisions much less stressful.
  • Hold your team accountable. CRM data replaces subjective assessments of performance with objective activity and results data.

Common CRM Mistakes to Avoid

Buying More CRM Than You Need

The most common mistake. A solo consultant does not need Salesforce. A 5-person service company does not need HubSpot Enterprise. Start with the simplest tool that solves your specific problems and upgrade only when you hit genuine limitations.

Treating the CRM as a Database Instead of a Workflow Tool

If you are using your CRM as a digital Rolodex — just storing contact information — you are using 10% of its value. The real power is in the pipeline, the automation, and the workflow. Deals should move through stages. Tasks should trigger follow-ups. Reports should inform decisions.

Not Cleaning Your Data

Over time, CRM data degrades. Contacts change jobs, phone numbers go stale, deals that were never properly closed sit in the pipeline forever. Schedule a monthly data hygiene session:

  • Close or archive deals that have been inactive for 90+ days
  • Merge duplicate contacts
  • Update contact information for active relationships
  • Remove contacts who are clearly irrelevant (they signed up for something once and will never be customers)

Customizing Everything Before Using It

Resist the urge to spend weeks customizing fields, pipelines, automations, and reports before you start using the CRM. You do not yet know what you actually need. Use the default setup for 30 days, note what is missing or unnecessary, then customize based on real experience.

Skipping Mobile Setup

If you talk to customers outside of your office — at job sites, in your car, at networking events — the mobile app is not optional. Set it up on day one and practice logging a call and adding a contact from your phone.

Your CRM Setup Checklist

Before You Buy

  • Defined your 3-5 specific pain points the CRM needs to solve
  • Identified how many users will need access
  • Listed the tools the CRM needs to integrate with
  • Set a realistic monthly budget per user
  • Tried at least 2-3 CRMs with free trials using real data

First Week Setup

  • Imported and cleaned your existing contacts
  • Customized pipeline stages to match your actual sales process
  • Added 3-5 custom fields for your most important data points
  • Connected your email account
  • Connected your calendar
  • Set up new lead notifications
  • Set up follow-up reminder automation
  • Installed the mobile app and logged in
  • Added your current deals to the pipeline

First 30 Days

  • Established a daily CRM routine (start of day, during day, end of day)
  • Logged every customer interaction in the CRM
  • Updated deal stages as they change
  • Reviewed and adjusted pipeline stages based on actual usage
  • Added any missing custom fields that became obvious

Ongoing Monthly

  • Reviewed pipeline value and conversion rates
  • Analyzed lead source performance
  • Cleaned data: merged duplicates, archived stale deals, updated contacts
  • Evaluated whether automation is working or needs adjustment
  • Assessed whether the CRM is solving your original pain points

A CRM is one of the highest-leverage investments a small business can make. It replaces chaos with system, guesswork with data, and forgotten follow-ups with closed deals. The key is choosing a tool that matches your actual needs, setting it up with intention, and building the daily habits that keep the data useful. Start simple, use it consistently, and let the system compound your efforts over time.