Is AI Search Traffic Worth Your Time? New Data Shows Surprising Conversion Rates

Everyone is talking about how AI tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini are changing search. For a local business owner, it’s easy to dismiss this as big-brand problems. After all, if someone wants a plumber or a local accountant, they still use Google, right?

But new data looking at 13 months of website traffic tells a different story. If you’re ignoring AI search, you might be missing out on your best customers.

Recent research analyzing how much traffic brands actually get from AI chatbots reveals some striking numbers. First, the reality check: AI refers less than 2% of total website traffic right now. From a sheer volume perspective, Google still rules completely.

But here is why you should care: that tiny trickle of AI traffic is growing at an average of 80% every six months. More importantly, the people clicking those AI links are buying.

The data shows that visitors coming from AI tools convert at around 18%. That is significantly higher than traditional SEO, paid shopping ads, or standard pay-per-click campaigns.

Why is the conversion rate so high? Because by the time an AI tool gives a user your link, their question is already answered and their intent is validated. They aren’t browsing; they are arriving ready to act.

What does this mean for your small business? First, don’t panic or dump your Google strategy. Volume still matters. But start paying attention to how AI platforms learn about businesses in your industry.

Interestingly, AI tools are increasingly pulling their answers from platforms like YouTube and Reddit. If you have been ignoring video or community platforms because “they don’t drive direct traffic,” it’s time to rethink that. Those platforms look like the training ground for the AI answers of tomorrow.

**Stop juggling a dozen tools to see what works.** SMBcrm helps small businesses manage contacts and marketing in one place. Try SMBcrm free →

Small business marketing has always been about making the most of limited resources. While you shouldn’t bet the farm on AI traffic today, treating it as a premium audience and ensuring your business information is clear, accurate, and available on the platforms AI trusts is a smart play for the future.